Google Restores Apps Amid Indian Developers Dispute: A Deep Dive into the Conflict

In a significant turn of events following a tense standoff, tech giant Google has commenced the process of reinstating Indian app developers it delisted from its Play Store on March 1, 2024. 

The decision to restore certain apps comes amidst a backdrop of heated negotiations, social media discussions, government pressure, and regulatory scrutiny surrounding Google's billing policies and its implications for Indian startups.

On March 4, the Indian government called a meeting of the affected Indian app developers and tech behemoth Google to listen to both parties on the ongoing issue.

The dispute, which erupted over Google's insistence on its billing system and the imposition of hefty service fees, has sparked widespread concern within the Indian tech ecosystem. 

On March 1, Google sent shockwaves through the Indian app developer community by removing 10 prominent developers from its Play Store, citing non-payment of service fees. 

This abrupt action thrust the simmering conflict between Google and Indian app developers into the spotlight, prompting widespread debate and scrutiny over the tech giant's policies and their impact on the digital ecosystem.

The affected apps, including Shaadi.com, Bharat Matrimony, Altt (formerly ALTBalaji), Kuku FM, Quack Quack, and others, have long been stalwarts of India's digital landscape, catering to diverse user needs and preferences.

“It feels like we will never be able to operate safely if our ecosystem is controlled by them. We need the Indian government to step in and save the startup ecosystem,” KuKu FM's Co-founder and CEO Lal Chand Bisu said on employment-focused social media platform LinkedIn.

The crux of the conflict lies in Google's Play Store policies, particularly its requirement for developers to use the Google Play Billing System (GPBS) and pay commissions ranging from 11% to 26% on in-app purchases. 

This move follows an order from the fair trade watchdog, Competition Commission of India (CCI), directing Google to revise its earlier system, which charged commissions as high as 30%, deeming it ‘anti-competitive’.

Despite the CCI's directives and efforts by affected startups to seek relief through legal channels, Google proceeded with the delisting after the Supreme Court declined to provide interim relief. This unilateral action by Google has raised questions about the fairness of its app marketplace fee and its potential impact on the Indian startup ecosystem.

Around 30 companies had written a letter to Google, requesting the company not to delist their apps or take any ‘precipitative action’ against them till March 19 as their Special Leave Petition (SLP) comes up for hearing, according to a Times of India report published on Feb 13, 2024

The app developers had filed the petition against the judgment delivered by the Madras High Court on January 19. The Supreme Court directed the SLP to be listed on March 19 and denied interim relief to startups.

It has also sparked a debate to develop in-house an indigenous app store that reflects a growing sentiment toward promoting homegrown solutions and reducing dependency on global tech giants like Google. 

In response to mounting pressure, Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw, from the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology, intervened to facilitate discussions between Google and the affected app developers. Minister Vaishnaw emphasized the importance of upholding India's policies and ensuring the protection of its startups in the digital marketplace.

In a rapid response after government intervention, Google has reinstated Info Edge's array of mobile applications, including popular platforms like Naukri, 99acres, and Shiksha, just one day after they were delisted from the tech giant's Play Store.

As per media reports, sources within Google revealed that the restoration of certain apps is contingent upon developers agreeing to comply with Android's billing options or opting for a consumption-only model. Under the consumption-only model, developers can provide access to paid content without incurring service fees, offering a potential workaround to Google's billing requirements.

While the restoration of apps signals a temporary postponement for affected developers, the broader implications of the conflict remain unresolved. 

The standoff between Google and Indian startups underscores the challenges of navigating the digital landscape, where tech giants wield immense power and influence over distribution channels and revenue streams.

However, the path to resolution remains fraught with challenges, as stakeholders navigate complex legal, regulatory, and commercial considerations. 

As discussions between stakeholders continue, there is a growing consensus on the need for greater transparency, fairness, and regulatory oversight in the digital ecosystem. 

As the saga unfolds, all eyes will be on the outcomes of negotiations and the steps taken by Google, Indian regulators, and app developers to find a resolution that balances innovation, competition, and consumer protection. 

The outcome of this dispute will not only shape the future of app development and distribution in India but also set a precedent for how tech companies interact with emerging markets and their burgeoning startup ecosystems.

In the meantime, the March 1 de-listings are a stark reminder of the power dynamics in the digital ecosystem and the importance of advocating for fair and transparent policies that foster a thriving and inclusive tech landscape.

Industry experts believe that it will be essential for policymakers, industry stakeholders, and the broader community to collaborate and support initiatives aimed at building indigenous solutions. 

"PhonePe launched the Indus app store in Q4 2023. But how many are using it? How many have even heard of it? The problem begins with Android and iOS being the major OS and thus having their default app distribution platforms pre-installed on the phones. Any other app distribution platform (such as Indus) cannot be listed on Google Play Store (or iOS Appstore),” replying to Lal Chand Bisu’s post, TopN Analytics Founder Harish Mahale said in his comments on LinkedIn. 

On February 21, Walmart-owned PhonePe unveiled the Indus Appstore, a new Android app marketplace in India, poised to compete with Google Play and other alternative app stores.

“Notably, Indus offers Indian developers the freedom to choose any third-party payment gateway for in-app billings, a stark contrast to Google Play's restrictions. This empowers developers and fosters a more competitive and diverse app marketplace. Embracing the IndusApp Store not only supports local innovation but also challenges monopolistic practices, contributing to India's digital sovereignty. #IndusAppStore #SupportIndianInnovation #BreakMonopolies," Ashish Kumar Shaw, State Head at PhonePe said in his comments on social networking site LinkedIn.

As per recent Indian Mobile App stats for 2024, India has claimed the top spot globally for the highest number of apps installed and actively used each month.

At present, Google Play serves as the designated app marketplace for the Android operating system, offering users the opportunity to discover and install apps and games developed using the Android software development kit (SDK).

There are 3,362,451 apps offered for free on Google Play, with an additional 107,095 apps requiring a purchase. However, it's worth noting that many of the free apps may necessitate subscriptions or include options for in-app purchases.

Google Removes Apps from Play Store | Mitron and Remove China Apps

Google removes apps Mitron and Remove China Apps from Google Play Store. 2 rival apps which had posed a challenge to the Chinese apps deleted from app list.

StartupTalkyAvantika Bhardwaj